America's 10 Best Islands

Posted Aug 24th 2010 11:46 AMUpdated Feb 1st 2011 04:14 AM




As America the Beautiful so lyrically states, our country extends "from sea to shining sea," and some of the greatest escapes in the U.S. are to the islands that line our eastern and western coast (and don't forget the Great Lakes). The islands all have their own personalities and there is something for everyone -- breathtaking hikes through national parks, inns housed in quaint Queen Anne manses, plus maritime history to spare. Take a ride on a lobster boat, go looking for orcas off an island with the same name, or just lay back and enjoy the sandy shores. No matter what you choose, you're guaranteed a vacation steeped in Americana.

Getty Images

10. Block Island, Rhode Island
Block Island makes the list for its dramatic scenery and seafaring history. You'll find 250-foot bullying bluffs guarding 17 miles of ivory-hued beaches, shimmering salt ponds, and ornate Victorian architecture (the Spring House Hotel has welcomed guests since 1854). The Block Island Historical Society, occupying an 1850 mansard-roof farmhouse, traces Native American and maritime heritage while Water Street hops in the evenings. Nearly half the island is preserved open space: moraine grasslands to marshes hosting more than 40 rare and endangered species, laced with 32 miles of tranquil trails for bikers, hikers and horseback riders. The less active can simply lounge on the beaches -- all public and free to all (including parking).

Fun Fact: Infamous buccaneer Captain Kidd frequented Block Island; local legend swears its small caves hold buried treasure.
Check out our Top 5 Travel Deals

Mini D, flickr

9. Key West, Florida
From corsairs to Cuban revolutionaries, Key West has long been synonymous with colorful characters. Its comparative isolation and spectacular scenery lures creative types, notably Tennessee Williams and Ernest Hemingway. Bike or stroll "Old Town," the Key West Historic District that embraces Mallory Square, Duval Street, the Truman Annex (site of Harry S.'s Winter White House), and Fort Zachary Taylor, as well as century-old pastel gingerbread-trim bungalows set on piers with peaked roofs and bougainvillea-draped balconies. Bustling Bahama Village, two centuries old, celebrates African cultural heritage. Seafaring traditions endure at Key West Bight, lined with seafood eateries and outfitters catering to those who want to get in or on the water to see its vibrant residents. Be prepared for a party atmosphere back on land: Thousands toast each sunset with almost pagan abandon at Mallory Square and locals joke you can smell the booze on the breeze along Duval Street.

Fun Fact: One of the Key West's many attractions is the iconic concrete "buoy" claiming "Southernmost Point Continental U.S.A."
Key West Travel Deals

10 Best American Islands

Steph & Adam, flickr

8. Mackinac Island, Michigan
Most motorized vehicles have been prohibited on Mackinac since 1898, preserving this 3.8-square-mile island's Victorian "living museum" charm. Architectural styles span 300 years, including Native American structures, rare 18th-century rustic French buildings, and the flamboyant Victorian summer "cottages" of railroad and lumber barons. History is everywhere: Whitewashed 1780 Fort Mackinac presents reenactments and you can watch hearth cooking and craft making at the 18th-century Biddle House. Mackinac Island State Park preserves most of the landscape, encompassing plant-rich meadows, boreal forest, and limestone formations. Birders can admire a rainbow of avian species, while duffers can attack the challenging Wawashkamo, a course that has been continuously played since 1898. Downtown offers butterfly conservatories, a haunted house with wax monsters, and shopping for renowned Mackinac Island Chocolate Fudge and Chippewa artifacts.

Fun Fact: Somewhere in Time director Jeannot Szwarc received a rare exemption to banned motorcars so that Christopher Reeve could drive up to the 1887 Grand Hotel for the movie's opening.
Mackinac Island Travel Deals


7. Mt. Desert Island, Maine
The rugged island of rocky coastlines, crystal lakes, and evergreen forests of Mt. Desert Island comprise most of Acadia National Park. Receding glaciers clawed the earth in their wake during the last Ice Age, leaving whale-backed ridges, U-shaped valleys and debris resembling abstract sculpture called erratic. The rising sea sculpted the eastern seaboard's only fjord, Somes Sound. Fabled Bar Harbor, founded in 1796, is the island's upscale yet unmistakably Down East gateway. Prominent families -- Rockefellers, Fords, Vanderbilts, Carnegies -- built elegant estate here and made a strong commitment to stewardship. Their original conservation efforts today protect more than 50 square miles of varied terrain. The Abbe Museum's displays span 10,000 years of history, art, and archaeology. See more by booking a catamaran cruise and gliding past historic lighthouses, fanciful formations, and the mansions along "Millionaires' Row." Or book a trip on a working lobster boat to see where tonight's dinner came from.

Fun Fact: Cadillac Mountain, the north Atlantic coast's highest point, provides jaw-dropping panoramas and during certain times of the year is the first U.S. spot to witness sunrise.
Book Mt. Desert Island Hotels

Allison Turrell, flickr

6. Mustang Island, Port Aransas, Texas
This 18-mile-long barrier island, connected by a causeway and 24-hour ferry to Corpus Christi, offers wildlife and wild life at party-hearty Port Aransas. Trolleys ply the historic honkytonk town, filled with down-home pubs and upscale galleries. Wide bay- and Gulf-side beaches, lined with dunes, seafood shanties and marinas, hikers, seashell collectors, and sandcastle architects (100,000 spectators ogle hundreds of entries at SandFest, the nation's largest sand-sculpting competition, every April). Aquatic activities abound: surfing waves off the jetty, kite-boarding off protected sandbars, casting for trophy tuna and tarpon. Tournaments lure international competitors, who spin tales of the ones that got away in fun funky bars. More than 500 bird species vacation here, dolphin frolic in the channel, and coyote roam Mustang Island State Park.

Fun Fact: Mark "Sand Man" Landrum acts as Port A's official "Sandcastle Dream Builder," offering lessons in engineering elaborate moats and machicolated battlements.
Port Aransas Travel Deals

Getty Images

5. Ocracoke Island, North Carolina
Outermost of the Outer Banks, Ocracoke is a 16-mile slash of unspoiled sand along the Cape Hatteras National Seashore. The remote isle was settled in the 1750s and history hounds can admire the East Coast's oldest operating lighthouse (built 1823) and browse Civil War artifacts at the Ocracoke Preservation Museum. Over 250 historic structures remain standing on the island (often on stilts), most utilizing materials from scuttled ships. The culinary, shopping, and nightlife scenes are worth the trip as well. Fisherman angle for Spanish mackerel and speckled trout, which is then served alongside oyster stew simmered with bacon at generations-old family-owned restaurants. Shops carry authentic crafts from quilts to woodcarvings, and CDs by such well-regarded locals as Molasses Creek and Mya Rose, who play bars like Deep Water Theater and Mango Loco.

Fun Fact: Isolated Ocracoke developed its own distinct dialect, a "brogue" which you can still distinguish among older residents.
Check out our Top 5 Travel Deals


4. Orcas Island, Washington
One of the hilly, verdant San Juan Islands, "The Rock" (as the locals call it) is blanketed with evergreen forests and stitched with sandy beaches perfect for zoning out. Madrona Point Park has nature paths and hundreds of twisting, ocher-hued madrona trees sprouting like restless spirits from the rocky shoreline, while Moran State Park has 5,200 acres of woodlands filigreed with waterfalls and lakes for swimming. The Orcas Island Historical Museum documents early island life in six original homestead cabins and the Crow Valley Museum, located in an 1888 territorial one-room schoolhouse, features furnishings, childhood memorabilia, and photographs. And, as the island's name implies, whale watching is one of the water recreations. Go May through October to see Orcas as well as Minke Whales.

Fun Fact: Local artists demonstrate their creative processes from blowing glass art to pottery in working studios in Olga's Orcas Island Artworks, a popular café/gallery in a former strawberry-barreling plant.

ralph and jenny, flickr

3. St. Simons Island, Georgia
The largest of Georgia's four Golden Isles, St. Simons has beckoned bluebloods and birders for a century with marshes, maritime forests, and Mediterranean Revival mansions. The island's location made it a strategic maritime point: Explore Fort Frederica National Monument, where colonists won a major naval battle during the Revolutionary war and learn more at the WPA-built 1935 Old Coast Guard Station that houses the Maritime Center museum. Golfers can play hundreds of challenging holes between St. Simons and neighboring Sea and Jekyll Islands. Patrol the waters on a working shrimp boat, sail on a dolphin-watching tour, or just bask on pearly sands.

Fun Fact: The 104-foot St. Simons Lighthouse (a working navigational beacon operational since 1872) and its brick Victorian light-keeper's residence were renovated in 2010.


2. Santa Catalina Island, California
Catalina combines historic ambience with wilderness allure by offering everything from Art Deco theaters to zip lines. Chewing gum magnate William Wrigley Jr. brought the Chicago Cubs here for spring training (they played on the island until 1952) and the historic clubhouse, now the Catalina Country Club & Golf Course, displays Cubbies memorabilia. Wrigley also built the ornate 1929 Catalina Casino. Take the tour to see the Deco reliefs, Tiffany chandeliers, and 180-foot-diameter parquet dance floor in the world's largest circular ballroom. Outdoorsy types should rest assured that the Catalina Island Conservancy acts as responsible steward, controlling approximately 88 percent of the island. Hiking, mountain biking, camping, and often diving permits must be obtained.

Fun Fact: Catalina, only 22 miles from Los Angeles, has been the backdrop for countless films and TV shows. The approximately 150 American bison that roam Catalina are descended from those imported for the 1924 filming of The Vanishing American. Due to cost overruns, producers left them on island (Catalina's scenes didn't even make the final cut).

petercruise, flickr

1. Shelter Island, New York
Tiny Shelter Island offers a lower-key atmosphere and attitude than the high-maintenance, celebrity-riddled Hamptons. The Nature Conservancy owns nearly one third of the island, protecting wetlands in their wild state. Stroll Shelter Island Heights, a classic Romantic rural residential development on the National Register of Historic Places. Natural terrain dictated the layout, optimizing water views-its 141 buildings (designed between 1872 and 1890 and virtually unchanged since) range from fanciful folk architecture to elaborately embellished Stick-Eastlake, Queen Anne, and Colonial Revival manses. Many now house charming inns and restaurants serving seasonal regional bounty.

Fun Fact: Ferry to Greenport and explore Long Island's emerging wine region. Most wineries respect the vernacular architecture, renovating old potato barns; several also reflect their owners' other passions, from world-class art collections to botanical gardens.
Shelter Island Travel Deals

Filed Under: Beach, Best Of

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:
Mary Keating

Cumberland Island off the Georgia coast should certainly be included in any list!! It's an unspoiled paradise. Wild horses, old mansions, beautiful beaches, and history make it a special place. It's a National Seashore. Visitors are limited. You get there only by ferry from St Marys, GA, a little town that makes you want to linger.

February 01 2011 at 6:27 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

I have a big confusion. I thought people working for National Geographic knew about world but I found a big mistake as I read in the tittle American's 10 Best Islands and as I know AMERICA IS A CONTINENT NOT A COUNTRY!!! believe me children learn this at school!!

But I have to say I just found a orientation problem or with names of continents and countries out of this the web site is amazing!!

Love National Geographic and this Islands from the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (USA) are incredible as well.

January 10 2011 at 8:25 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Catalina might not be great to other people, but to me it is....
Catalina Island is where I was born and raised.... Glad it made it to the tops =)

December 19 2010 at 6:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David Josephson

Shelter Island is just absolutely stunning. We have 2 Vacation Rentals in this Hamptons location that have received a lot of press and mostly all 5 star reviews. Take a look and let us know what you think., the #1 Island as ranked by AOL Travel!

November 09 2010 at 2:56 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Port A Parrot Head

Not old, not crabby, and waaaay too busy! I too pick up after tourists and others who don't care what happens to the earth. My point is that a pipeline draining into the Gulf from 150 miles away isn't responsible for any murkiness in our water and that we DON'T have Houston's waste draining right here, which is what the previous poster was implying. If you could see the water today, you'd know why Mustang made it on this list. It's been absolutely beautiful here lately and hardly any tourists to muck it up! Most folks come in the summer when the Gulf isn't at its finest and then make sweeping assumptions. The whole world drains into the oceans, so Houston is not any more guilty than any place else. Don't jump to conclusions, Shanon. Educate, research, stupidity? Hmmmm. We welcome anyone who will treat our beach home with respect so that they too can enjoy one of Nature's greatest gifts.

October 07 2010 at 7:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Linda McCarthy

This is a fabulous, accurate list of our US island treasures. As a permanent resident of Shelter Island, I was happy to see it at the top! If I can help anyone in planning a visit to beautiful Shelter Island, please contact me at I am a Licensed Salesperson with Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty and we handle the full range of Rentals and Sales on Shelter Island.

October 04 2010 at 10:22 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Whaaaaat?!?!? Hawaiiiiii... At least 2-3 Hawaiian islands make it to EVERY Top 10. That's why this Top AMERICA'S Best Islands is a mistake.

September 28 2010 at 12:46 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
York Phillips

Excellent information. There are many islands worth visiting, and this list represents a great start. For people looking to visit St. Simons Island, Georgia, check for information on what is happening.

September 18 2010 at 10:25 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kathryn O\'Hagan

Shelter Island's best beach: Bootlegger's Alley at the very end of West Neck Road. Quiet retreat, town boat launch, and crab creek for kayaking...

September 16 2010 at 11:53 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
William Price

Great job. I've set foot on 7 of the 10. Grew up on Shelter Island - graduated from Shelter Island High School, class of '68. The best place I've been to except for the spot I'm living in now.

September 16 2010 at 10:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Around the Web

  • Even when you're traveling, follow what's going on in your neighborhood.
    Get the Patch app.
  • .